Skip to content
Boilers.caby ROMA Heating & Cooling

Comparison

A. O. Smith Burkay HW-300 vs HW-420

Verdict in brief

The Burkay HW-300 and HW-420 are two sizes of the same commercial copper hot water boiler: 300,000 versus 420,000 BTU/h input, 1-1/4" versus 1-1/2" water connections, and 250 versus 301 lb shipping weight. Both are 160 psi ASME-tested, run natural gas or propane, and share the same burner and non-ferrous waterway construction; the choice is the building's hot-water load.

Side by side

Published manufacturer figures. Input and output are kept separate; blanks mean the manufacturer did not publish that value.

Comparison of A. O. Smith Burkay HW-300 and A. O. Smith Burkay HW-420
SpecificationA. O. Smith Burkay HW-300A. O. Smith Burkay HW-420
Input rating300,000 BTU/h natural and propane420,000 BTU/h natural and propane
Output ratingNot present in the AOSDG25600 PDF text layer336,000 BTU/h
Water inlet / outlet1-1/4" NPT inlet / 1-1/4" NPT outlet1-1/2" NPT inlet / 1-1/2" NPT outlet
Gas inlet3/4" NPT1" NPT
Draft diverter outlet diameter8 in10 in
Approximate shipping weight250 lb301 lb
Recovery capacity (as printed)1,455 GPH at 20 °F rise (natural gas)2,036 GPH at 20 °F rise (natural gas)

What actually separates them

Both models come from the current Conservationist Burkay commercial gas hot water boiler line documented in spec sheet AOSDG25600 (© October 2024). The HW-300 is rated 300,000 BTU/h input and the HW-420 420,000 BTU/h, both on natural gas or propane. The spec sheet prints an output rating of 336,000 BTU/h for the HW-420; the HW-300's output cell is not extractable from the published PDF and is recorded as not captured rather than assumed at a percentage.

The connection envelope grows with size: 1-1/4" NPT water inlet and outlet on the HW-300 against 1-1/2" on the HW-420, while the gas inlet is 3/4" on the smaller model and 1" on the larger. The draft diverter outlet rises from 8" to 10". Recovery at a 20 °F rise is 1,455 GPH for the HW-300 and 2,036 GPH for the HW-420.

Both boilers share the same construction and ratings framework: all non-ferrous waterways (copper tubes with bronze and brass castings), the Burkay burner with up to 72 primary-air orifices, ASME 160 psi certification, a 125 psi relief valve and indoor-only installation. Neither the spec sheet nor the product page prints an efficiency percentage, so no efficiency comparison is made. Size from the building's domestic hot-water load.

CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
Not present in the AOSDG25600 PDF text layer
AFUE
—

The A. O. Smith Burkay HW-300 is a commercial gas-fired copper hot water boiler rated 300,000 BTU/h input, with 1-1/4" NPT water connections and a 3/4" NPT gas connection.

Natural gasPropaneHeating-only
CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
336,000 BTU/h
AFUE
—

The A. O. Smith Burkay HW-420 is a commercial gas-fired copper hot water boiler rated 420,000 BTU/h input and 336,000 BTU/h output, with 1-1/2" NPT water connections and a 1" NPT gas connection.

Natural gasPropaneHeating-only

Frequently asked questions

How much bigger is the Burkay HW-420 than the HW-300?

AOSDG25600 prints 420,000 versus 300,000 BTU/h input, and recovery at 20 °F rise of 2,036 versus 1,455 GPH. The HW-420 also moves up to 1-1/2" water and 1" gas connections.

Do both run on propane?

Yes. Tables 2 and 3 of the spec sheet print natural gas and propane rows for every Burkay HW size.

Is an efficiency rating printed?

No efficiency percentage is printed on the Burkay spec sheet; it states that the models meet DOE thermal-efficiency and standby-loss requirements without a number.

Not sure which one fits your home?

A consultation includes a heat-loss review so the size is right the first time.

On-site service in Greater Vancouver, BC. ROMA lists “Open 7 days” on its site; call to confirm same-day availability.

Sources and verification

Facts checked September 9, 2026. Last updated September 9, 2026. Technical reviewer: not yet assigned.

CallEmailEstimate