Skip to content
Boilers.caby ROMA Heating & Cooling

Comparison

Pennco 1603HSID vs Pennco 1604HSID

Verdict in brief

Both the Pennco 1603HSID and the Pennco 1604HSID belong to the Pennco 16 Series line of non-condensing boilers. Published ratings: Pennco 1603HSID at 75 / 70 MBH input, 62 / 58 MBH heating capacity and 82.7% AFUE; Pennco 1604HSID at 112 / 105 MBH input, 91 / 85 MBH heating capacity and 82% AFUE. The published input differs: Pennco 1603HSID lists 75 / 70 MBH, while Pennco 1604HSID lists 112 / 105 MBH. Pennco 1603HSID carries the higher published AFUE at 82.7%, against 82%. Pennco 1604HSID lists 71 lb more shipping weight than Pennco 1603HSID (368 lb against 297 lb).

Side by side

Published manufacturer figures. Input and output are kept separate; blanks mean the manufacturer did not publish that value.

Comparison of Pennco 1603HSID and Pennco 1604HSID
SpecificationPennco 1603HSIDPennco 1604HSID
Input (natural gas / LP)75 / 70 MBH112 / 105 MBH
Heating capacity (natural gas / LP)62 / 58 MBH91 / 85 MBH
Efficiency (AFUE)82.7 %82 %
Domestic hot waterHeating-only boiler — domestic hot water comes from a separate indirect tank or water heaterHeating-only boiler — domestic hot water comes from a separate indirect tank or water heater
Approx. shipping weight297 lb368 lb
Dimensions (width × height × depth)11-1/4" × 36-3/8" × 26-1/2"14-1/2" × 36-3/8" × 26-1/2"
VentingChimney vented with integral draft diverterChimney vented with integral draft diverter
Steam connections2" supply and 2" return2" supply and 2" return
ControlIntermittent pilot control with continuous retry and 100% shut-offIntermittent pilot control with continuous retry and 100% shut-off
FuelNatural gas or propane (conversion kits available)Natural gas or propane (conversion kits available)
Net steam (natural gas / LP)47 / 44 MBH68 / 64 MBH
Steam square feet (natural gas / LP)195 / 183 sq ft283 / 267 sq ft
Flue diameter5"6"

What actually separates them

Published ratings: the Pennco 1603HSID is rated 75 / 70 MBH input, 62 / 58 MBH heating capacity and 82.7% AFUE; the Pennco 1604HSID is rated 112 / 105 MBH input, 91 / 85 MBH heating capacity and 82% AFUE. The published input differs: Pennco 1603HSID lists 75 / 70 MBH, while Pennco 1604HSID lists 112 / 105 MBH. Pennco 1603HSID carries the higher published AFUE at 82.7%, against 82%.

Pennco 1604HSID lists 71 lb more shipping weight than Pennco 1603HSID (368 lb against 297 lb). The dimensions differs: the Pennco 1603HSID lists 11-1/4" × 36-3/8" × 26-1/2", while the Pennco 1604HSID lists 14-1/2" × 36-3/8" × 26-1/2". The flue diameter differs: the Pennco 1603HSID lists 5", while the Pennco 1604HSID lists 6".

Both records print the same domestic-hot-water arrangement (Heating-only boiler — domestic hot water comes from a separate indirect tank or water heater), venting (Chimney vented with integral draft diverter), water connections (2" supply and 2" return) and control (Intermittent pilot control with continuous retry and 100% shut-off), per the cited sources.

CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
—
AFUE
82.7 %

The Pennco 1603HSID is the smallest 16 Series size and the only 82.7% AFUE row: 75/70 MBH input (natural gas/LP) with 62/58 MBH heating capacity and a 47/44 MBH net steam rating at 82.7% AFUE.

Natural gasPropaneHeating-only
CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
—
AFUE
82 %

The Pennco 1604HSID is the second 16 Series size: 112/105 MBH input (natural gas/LP) with 91/85 MBH heating capacity and a 68/64 MBH net steam rating at 82% AFUE.

Natural gasPropaneHeating-only

Frequently asked questions

How do the published input figures compare?

The Pennco 1603HSID lists 75 / 70 MBH, while the Pennco 1604HSID lists 112 / 105 MBH, per the cited documentation.

Which model is more efficient?

The Pennco 1603HSID carries the higher published AFUE at 82.7%, against 82%.

How much heavier is the Pennco 1604HSID?

It ships at 368 lb against 297 lb for the Pennco 1603HSID, per the cited sources.

Not sure which one fits your home?

A consultation includes a heat-loss review so the size is right the first time.

On-site service in Greater Vancouver, BC. ROMA lists “Open 7 days” on its site; call to confirm same-day availability.

Sources and verification

Facts checked September 9, 2026. Last updated September 9, 2026. Technical reviewer: not yet assigned.

CallEmailEstimate