Skip to content
Boilers.caby ROMA Heating & Cooling

Comparison

Burnham Independence IN4I vs Burnham SteamMax STMX125

Verdict in brief

The Burnham Independence IN4I and Burnham SteamMax STMX125 are both non-condensing boilers in the Burnham SteamMax & Independence (gas steam) line. The Burnham Independence IN4I is rated 65 MBH net AHRI steam rating and 82% AFUE, and the Burnham SteamMax STMX125 is rated 77 MBH net AHRI steam rating and 82% AFUE. Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 12 MBH more net AHRI steam rating than Burnham Independence IN4I (77 MBH against 65 MBH). Both list the same published AFUE of 82%. Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 180 lb more shipping weight than Burnham Independence IN4I (600 lb against 420 lb).

Side by side

Published manufacturer figures. Input and output are kept separate; blanks mean the manufacturer did not publish that value.

Comparison of Burnham Independence IN4I and Burnham SteamMax STMX125
SpecificationBurnham Independence IN4IBurnham SteamMax STMX125
Efficiency (AFUE)82 %82 %
Approximate shipping weight420 lb600 lb
FuelNatural gas or LP gas (on select chimney-vented models)Natural gas only
Net AHRI steam rating65 MBH77 MBH
ConstructionCast-iron sections with push nipples, Honeywell operating controls, vent damper and insulated steel jacketCast-iron sectional design with metal push nipples, wide waterways, heat transfer pins below the water line and a large steam chest
WarrantyLimited 10-year heat exchanger warranty plus a one-year manufacturer's parts warranty10-year limited heat exchanger warranty and 10-year limited waterside corrosion warranty

What actually separates them

Published ratings: the Burnham Independence IN4I is rated 65 MBH net AHRI steam rating and 82% AFUE; the Burnham SteamMax STMX125 is rated 77 MBH net AHRI steam rating and 82% AFUE. Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 12 MBH more net AHRI steam rating than Burnham Independence IN4I (77 MBH against 65 MBH). Both list the same published AFUE of 82%.

Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 180 lb more shipping weight than Burnham Independence IN4I (600 lb against 420 lb). The fuel differs: the Burnham Independence IN4I lists Natural gas or LP gas (on select chimney-vented models), while the Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists Natural gas only. The construction differs: the Burnham Independence IN4I lists Cast-iron sections with push nipples, Honeywell operating controls, vent damper and insulated steel jacket, while the Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists Cast-iron sectional design with metal push nipples, wide waterways, heat transfer pins below the water line and a large steam chest. The warranty differs: the Burnham Independence IN4I lists Limited 10-year heat exchanger warranty plus a one-year manufacturer's parts warranty, while the Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 10-year limited heat exchanger warranty and 10-year limited waterside corrosion warranty.

Both models are documented by the official Burnham sources cited on their model records; the shared values above are taken from those documents.

CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
—
AFUE
82 %

The Burnham Independence IN4I is a current gas-fired cast-iron steam boiler: 105 MBH maximum input for 87 MBH heating capacity and a 65 MBH net AHRI steam rating (271 sq ft) at 82% AFUE, requiring a 5 in. x 15 ft chimney and shipping at about 420 lb.

Natural gasPropaneHeating-only
CurrentCanadian status unknown
Input
—
Output (max)
—
AFUE
82 %

The Burnham SteamMax STMX125 is a current gas-fired cast-iron steam boiler: 125 MBH input for 103 MBH output and a 77 MBH net AHRI steam rating (321 sq ft) at 82% AFUE, with 4 sections, a 6" vent and a 1/2" NPT gas connection.

Natural gasHeating-only

Frequently asked questions

Which of the two has the higher maximum net AHRI steam rating?

The Burnham SteamMax STMX125 lists 77 MBH, against 65 MBH on the Burnham Independence IN4I, per the cited documentation.

Which model is more efficient?

Both list the same AFUE of 82%.

How much heavier is the Burnham SteamMax STMX125?

It ships at 600 lb against 420 lb for the Burnham Independence IN4I, per the cited sources.

Not sure which one fits your home?

A consultation includes a heat-loss review so the size is right the first time.

On-site service in Greater Vancouver, BC. ROMA lists “Open 7 days” on its site; call to confirm same-day availability.

Sources and verification

Facts checked September 9, 2026. Last updated September 9, 2026. Technical reviewer: not yet assigned.

CallEmailEstimate