Two storage philosophies for the same need
Domestic hot water can be delivered from storage or made on demand, and the choice between an indirect tank and a tankless water heater is really a choice between those two philosophies. An indirect tank is a storage vessel with no burner of its own: a coil inside the tank carries hot water from the boiler, and the boiler reheats the stored supply between uses. A tankless water heater is the opposite shape of appliance: a burner and heat exchanger that light only when a tap opens and cold water flows through, producing hot water continuously but only at the rate the appliance can manage.
The two names describe different roles in the system, which is worth stating plainly because they are often compared as if they were rival boilers. The indirect tank has no independent heat source; it is an accessory of the boiler. The tankless water heater is a complete, self-contained appliance with its own burner, commonly a condensing unit in its own right, and it does not care how the home is heated. On this site the distinction shows up in the product lines: IBC, for example, documents heating-only boilers that connect directly to an indirect tank, and separately documents its SFT tankless water heater as a standalone condensing appliance, both on its Canadian pages.
'Storage hot water boiler' means more than one thing
The phrase 'storage hot water boiler' is used loosely, and the looseness matters when a homeowner is deciding what to buy. In some discussions it means an indirect tank: a storage vessel with no burner of its own, heated by the home's boiler through a coil, so the boiler does the work and the tank holds the result. In others it means a standalone tank-style water heater, a self-contained storage appliance with its own burner and flue that heats water independently of the heating system. Both store hot water; only the first depends on the boiler.
The distinction decides what is really being compared. In a Greater Vancouver home that already heats with a hydronic boiler, the question is usually the indirect-tank version: keep using the boiler to reheat a tank, or replace or supplement it with a condensing tankless water heater that makes hot water on demand and needs no storage. The comparison in this guide is written for that situation, because it is the one that changes scope on a boiler project. Where a home has no boiler, or heats with electricity or a heat pump, the choice is between a standalone storage water heater and a tankless unit, and the same draw-pattern logic still applies.
What stored hot water buys, and what it costs
Storage buys reserve. An indirect tank sized to the household holds a volume of hot water ready for a full tub, a long shower or two bathrooms running at once, and recovery happens afterwards, at the boiler's pace, rather than during the draw. That reserve is the reason indirect tanks remain the default for larger homes and for households whose peak moments arrive several at a time. Storage also decouples the burner from the tap: the boiler can reheat the tank at a modest firing rate whenever the heating load leaves capacity, which suits a modulating condensing boiler that prefers long, gentle runs.
The costs of storage are space, standby losses and a dependency chain. The tank occupies floor area beside the boiler, keeps its stored water warm between uses, and relies on the boiler for reheating, so a boiler outage pauses tank recovery even though the stored volume keeps serving draws in the meantime. The tank also has its own small maintenance life, and its insulation and controls age with the system.
What on-demand production buys, and its limit
A condensing tankless water heater spends almost all its life idle and fires only when water flows, which removes the tank's standby losses and its floor footprint entirely. It mounts on a wall, and because it is a sealed condensing appliance, it vents in certified plastic pipe like a boiler. For a household whose hot-water events are short and sequential, one shower after another through the morning, an on-demand unit covers the pattern without ever holding a reservoir warm, which is a genuine operating difference, not a marketing one.
The limit is the same one that constrains combi boilers: instantaneous flow. The unit can deliver only as much hot water per minute as its burner can heat, and the delivery rate falls in winter as the incoming supply gets colder. A large tub fill or two simultaneous showers can exceed the unit's rate, and the water temperature at the fixture starts to fall. Tankless sizing is therefore a flow calculation against the household's largest realistic simultaneous demand, made with the winter supply temperature, not a volume comparison against the tank's gallons.
| Characteristic | Indirect tank (heated by the boiler) | Condensing tankless water heater |
|---|---|---|
| Heat source | The home's boiler, through a coil | Its own burner and heat exchanger |
| Hot-water delivery | Stored reserve, available instantly in volume | On demand; limited by the unit's flow rate |
| Space | Floor-standing tank beside the boiler | Wall-hung appliance; no storage |
| Simultaneous draws | Served from storage while the tank recovers | Only up to the unit's continuous delivery rate |
| Standby losses | Stored water cools between uses | None; fires only when water flows |
| Dependency | Stops recovering if the boiler is down | Independent of the heating system |
| Typical fit | Larger homes, several bathrooms, high simultaneous demand | Compact homes, low simultaneous demand, no space for a tank |
Reading the delivery claims honestly
Both manufacturers and well-meaning sellers quote delivery figures that only apply under stated conditions, and the honest way to compare the two arrangements is to test both against the same household moment: the largest realistic simultaneous draw, on a cold January day. For the tank, the question is whether the stored volume plus the boiler's recovery rate covers the household's morning pattern. For the tankless unit, the question is whether its continuous delivery at the winter supply temperature covers the peak single moment, because on-demand units have no reserve to fall back on.
It is also fair to notice that the two arrangements answer different questions about the heating system. An indirect tank assumes a boiler is already in the building and simply extends it, which is why a home replacing a boiler often keeps the sound indirect tank rather than adding a second appliance. A tankless water heater answers the hot-water question independently, which suits homes whose heating is electric, a heat pump, or a boiler that the owner does not want to enlarge the job around.
Sizing a tank and sizing an on-demand unit are different calculations
The two options are chosen from the same household information but by different arithmetic, and treating one like the other is a common reason a choice disappoints. An indirect tank is sized from stored volume plus recovery: how much hot water the tank holds, how quickly the boiler can reheat it through the coil between draws, and how much the household uses before recovery finishes. Manufacturer literature describes this combined figure as the tank's first-hour rating, because what matters is not the stored volume alone but how much hot water the arrangement can deliver in its busiest hour.
An on-demand unit is sized as a flow problem instead. Its output is a temperature rise at a given flow rate, and the rise it must deliver grows as the incoming water gets colder, so a unit that keeps up in September can fall short in January. The figure to design around is the largest realistic simultaneous draw, such as two showers and a dishwasher at once, measured against the unit's delivery at the coldest supply temperature the home sees.
That difference explains why one household can be an easy fit for the tank and a poor fit for on-demand production on the same day. A home with a large tub and overlapping morning users may pass an on-demand unit's average use and still fail its peak moment, because there is no reserve to draw on. A home whose draws are small and spaced out may never need the reserve a tank provides, and pays for it in floor space and standing loss instead. The assessment on this site works from the draw pattern before it works from the equipment.
| Question | Indirect tank (heated by the boiler) | On-demand (tankless or combi) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary measure | Stored volume plus the boiler's recovery rate | Continuous flow at the required temperature rise |
| Worst case to design for | Total hot water drawn in the busiest hour | Largest simultaneous draw on the coldest supply |
| What changes the answer | Tank size, boiler recovery, coil performance | Incoming water temperature, fixture flow rates, unit capacity |
| How it fails when undersized | Hot water runs cool late in a heavy draw | Temperature drops during a simultaneous draw |
The draw-pattern questions to answer first
Before any model is discussed, a household can answer a short list of questions that decide most of the choice. The answers do not require equipment knowledge, and they are the same ones the consultation service on this site works through.
- How many people draw hot water in the same half hour, and do their showers overlap?
- Is there a large soaker tub, a multi-head shower or a body-spray setup that fills from the same supply?
- Does the dishwasher or washing machine run while people are showering?
- How many bathrooms does the home have, and how many are used at once?
- How cold is the incoming water in January, when an on-demand unit's delivery is at its lowest?
- Is there floor space beside the boiler for a tank, and can it be moved in and serviced there?
- Does the household want hot water to keep working if the heating boiler is down?
What each option needs installed: venting, gas, electrical and condensate
The two paths differ in what has to be installed, because one is an accessory of the boiler and the other is a complete gas appliance. That difference is the practical core of the comparison, and it shows up in every quote.
An indirect tank has no burner, flue or gas connection of its own. The boiler carries the sealed vent, the gas supply, the condensate drain and the electrical connection, and the tank adds a coil circuit piped to the boiler, a circulator and priority control, a mixing valve to limit the water temperature delivered to fixtures, and the floor area and clearance to service it. Because the tank produces no combustion, it adds no second vent and no second gas line.
A standalone condensing tankless water heater is a complete appliance: its own sealed combustion system venting in certified plastic pipe to an approved terminal, its own gas connection, its own condensate drain, and an electrical supply for its fan, ignition and controls. It mounts on a wall rather than the floor, which is the space advantage that makes it attractive where a tank will not fit.
| Requirement | Indirect tank (heated by the boiler) | Condensing tankless water heater |
|---|---|---|
| Burner and flue | None of its own; heated by the boiler | Its own burner and sealed combustion system |
| Venting | None added; the boiler vents | Its own sealed plastic vent to an exterior terminal |
| Gas connection | None added; the boiler is connected | Its own gas connection, sized to its input |
| Condensate | None produced; the boiler drains its own | Its own condensate drain |
| Electrical | Controlled with the boiler | Its own supply for fan, ignition and controls |
| Space | Floor-standing tank beside the boiler | Wall-hung appliance; no storage |
| Extra controls | Coil circuit, circulator, priority control and a mixing valve | Contained in the appliance |
Standby loss, recovery and a Greater Vancouver winter
The operating difference between storage and on-demand shows up in two places: what happens between draws, and what happens on the coldest morning of the year.
A stored tank keeps its water warm between uses, so it loses some heat continuously; the boiler replaces that loss at a modest firing rate, which is a comfortable match for a modulating condensing boiler that prefers long, gentle runs. A tankless unit avoids that standing loss entirely because it fires only when water flows, but when it does fire it fires hard to raise cold water to temperature as it passes through.
Recovery is where the reserve pays off. A large draw is served from the tank's stored volume while the boiler reheats the tank afterwards, so the household does not have to wait for the appliance to keep up in the moment. A tankless unit has no reserve, so it must meet the draw as it happens, and it can deliver only as much hot water per minute as its burner can heat.
Greater Vancouver's winter sharpens that difference. Incoming mains water is colder in winter, and a tankless unit's delivery is a temperature rise at a flow rate, so colder supply means a smaller volume of hot water per minute at the same setting. A stored tank buffers the cold because it fills and reheats over time rather than in the instant of the draw. Neither arrangement is automatically cheaper to run; the difference depends on the models, the controls, the draw pattern and how well each is matched to the household.
One maintenance point is common to both. FortisBC and Natural Resources Canada both describe an annual pre-season check-up by a licensed contractor as the way to keep a gas heating appliance safe and efficient, and where the water leaves scale behind, the tankless manufacturer's flushing routine becomes part of that schedule.
Recirculation loops and how quickly hot water arrives
The time a tap takes to run hot is a plumbing question as much as an appliance question, and it is one of the differences a household notices every day. Hot water left standing in the pipe between the heat source and the fixture cools between uses, so the first draw clears that cooled water before hot water arrives. A recirculation loop addresses this by keeping a small flow moving through the hot-water piping, or by returning cooled water to the source, so the run stays primed.
A stored arrangement is the natural home for a loop. An indirect tank is a reservoir the loop can return water to, and the boiler simply holds the tank at temperature. An on-demand unit holds no reservoir to circulate, so where a home already has a recirculation loop, the manufacturer's documentation and the installer confirm how the specific model is designed to work with it rather than assuming it will. That is a model-by-model question, not a general one.
For a home without a loop, the useful comparison is to time the actual run at the fixtures the household uses most. The answer depends on the length and insulation of the pipe run and on whether a loop exists, and it is a practical question the consultation service on this site works through before equipment is proposed.
What a power interruption does to each arrangement
A power interruption is a different event from a boiler failure, and the two arrangements behave differently in it. Every modern gas appliance needs electricity for its fan, ignition and controls, so neither a boiler nor a tankless unit can fire while the power is out. The difference is what is already in the tank and the pipes.
A stored arrangement holds a volume of hot water that was heated before the outage. That reserve continues to serve taps until it is drawn down, even though the boiler cannot reheat it. An on-demand unit has no reserve, so when the power goes out the hot water stops at the same moment the appliance does, and it resumes only when power returns and a tap calls again.
That is a resilience question rather than an efficiency one, and it is worth naming honestly: storage buys a buffer of hot water that survives a short outage, at the cost of standing loss and floor space, while on-demand production gives up the buffer in exchange for a smaller footprint and no stored water. Neither behaviour makes one arrangement safer, and both are gas appliances that must be serviced annually and, where the manufacturer specifies it, flushed. A household that has experienced long outages and values hot water during them has a legitimate reason to weigh storage, while a household that has not may not care about the difference at all.
Hard water, scale and each arrangement's water side
A hydronic or domestic system can accumulate scale and corrosion products over its life, and a home that has topped up a system repeatedly or filled from a mineral-rich source gives the water side more to work with. That matters to both arrangements, in different places.
An indirect tank transfers heat through a coil inside the tank, and scale on that coil insulates it the same way scale on a boiler's heat exchanger does: the boiler has to run hotter to move the same heat into the stored water. The tank is also a vessel of potable water, so its interior and any anode are part of what ages. A tankless unit has its own heat exchanger, and a narrow, hot water path is exactly where scale forms first; that is why the manufacturer's flushing routine exists and why it becomes part of the maintenance schedule where the water leaves deposits.
The common remedy is the same discipline in both cases: test the water, treat the hydronic loop with an inhibitor matched to its metals, and follow the appliance's own flushing or service requirements. The water-treatment service on this site covers the hydronic side, and the annual service is where a change in the water or in the appliance's behaviour is first noticed.
Cost, servicing and resilience
The two paths differ in what must be bought, installed and later maintained, and that scope — not a single published figure — is what a quote reflects. Boilers.ca publishes no prices; a written number follows an assessment. An indirect tank assumes the home already has a boiler, so a boiler replacement or repair can leave the storage side untouched, and the tank adds no burner, flue or gas connection of its own. A standalone tankless water heater is a complete second appliance: it brings its own venting, gas supply, water connections and condensate route, which is more installation content but keeps domestic hot water independent of the heating system.
Servicing follows the same split. An indirect tank has few moving parts and no combustion of its own, so annual attention centres on the boiler and a check of the tank, its coil and its controls, alongside the routine FortisBC recommends and Natural Resources Canada describes. A tankless unit carries its own burner, heat exchanger and sensors, and where the water leaves scale behind, the manufacturer's flushing routine becomes part of the maintenance schedule. Resilience also differs: if the boiler goes down, an indirect tank stops recovering but its stored volume keeps serving taps until it is drawn down, whereas a tankless failure removes hot water immediately because there is no reserve. Neither is automatically more reliable; it is a question of which failure a household would rather have, and when.
Which arrangement fits a Greater Vancouver household
Draw pattern, space and the state of the existing system usually settle it. Homes in Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond, Surrey, Coquitlam and the North Shore with several bathrooms, a large tub or overlapping morning users tend to be served best by stored hot water, whether that is an indirect tank kept from the current system or a correctly sized replacement. Compact homes, suites and laneway houses with short, sequential draws and no floor space for a tank are the natural fit for on-demand production, and a household that wants hot water to keep working independently of the heating boiler has a separate, legitimate reason to prefer a tankless unit.
Whichever path is chosen, the work is regulated gas work. In BC, installing a boiler, a tankless water heater or the gas piping that serves them requires a permit and inspection under Technical Safety BC, qualifying single-family owners may hold the permit themselves in the cases Technical Safety BC describes, and strata and duplex owners must use a licensed contractor who applies on their behalf. ROMA Heating & Cooling carries out installation, replacement, repair and maintenance for both arrangements in Greater Vancouver, and the consultation service on this site works through the draw pattern before any equipment is proposed.
Making the choice, and the installation side
The practical test is the draw pattern. Homes with several bathrooms, a large tub or overlapping users will find the tank's reserve the difference between a comfortable morning and a cold one; compact households with sequential draws can be served faithfully by the tankless unit, and gain back the floor space. When both arrangements are plausible, the tie-breakers are the state of the existing boiler and tank, the available space, and whether the owner wants one appliance or two to maintain.
Either way, the gas work is regulated the same way: in BC, installation of the boiler, the tankless heater or the tank's piping requires gas-permit and inspection processes under Technical Safety BC, homeowners in single-family homes may hold the permit in the cases Technical Safety BC describes, and strata owners use a licensed contractor. On this site the consultation service works through draw patterns, space and the existing system before equipment is proposed; the installation and replacement services, delivered with ROMA Heating & Cooling in Greater Vancouver, cover both arrangements, and the instant estimator gives a ballpark range for each path.